EmailSchool

Sender reputation is the most important part of email deliverability. If inbox providers trust your domain and your sending patterns, your emails land in the inbox consistently. If your reputation weakens, even your best campaigns will slide into Promotions or Spam. Inside Brevo, reputation management is a mix of technical authentication, engagement quality, sending behavior, and list hygiene. When all four pillars work together, your performance becomes predictable and stable.

This hybrid guide blends advanced technical knowledge with everyday practical strategies. You’ll learn how inbox providers evaluate reputation, how Brevo reacts to engagement signals, how warm-up schedules protect your domain, and how to fix reputation errors before they escalate. Whether you’re recovering from low open rates or building a fresh domain, this blueprint covers everything.

What Is Sender Reputation?

Sender reputation is your “email trust score.” Every inbox provider (Gmail, Yahoo, Outlook, Apple Mail) assigns a score to your domain based on:

Your open rates
Your bounce rates
Your spam complaints
Your engagement consistency
Your sender identity setup
Your authentication accuracy
Your list hygiene practices

High reputation means inbox placement. Low reputation means your emails silently disappear.

The 4 Core Elements of Sender Reputation

1. Authentication (SPF, DKIM, DMARC, BIMI)

Authentication proves that you are the real sender. Brevo provides automated DNS entries for:

SPF — verifies allowed sending servers
DKIM — signs your messages cryptographically
DMARC — sets rules for suspicious activity
BIMI — displays a verified brand logo in inboxes

Incorrect or missing authentication lowers inbox placement instantly.

2. Engagement Signals

Inbox providers rank your reputation based on how subscribers behave:

High opens → trust increases
High clicks → trust increases
No opens → trust decreases
Spam complaints → trust collapses
Bounces → trust weakens

3. Sending Patterns

Predictable, consistent sending looks safe. Chaotic sending looks suspicious.

Send same days
Send similar times
Send consistent volumes

Erratic sending causes throttling or delay.

4. List Hygiene

Your list must be clean. High numbers of inactive subscribers damage your reputation heavily.

Key Tip: If 30–40% of your list never opens emails, remove them. In Brevo, inactive contacts destroy your reputation faster than any other factor.

Technical Reputation Management (Advanced)

1. Warm-Up Schedules

When you use a new domain or restart email marketing, never send in bulk immediately. Use this schedule:

Day 1: 50 emails
Day 2: 100 emails
Day 3: 200 emails
Day 4: 400 emails
Day 5: 800 emails

Warm-ups teach inbox filters to trust your domain.

2. Bounce Management

Hard bounces and repeated soft bounces are red flags. Brevo auto-suppresses bad contacts, but you must audit them monthly.

3. Authenticate All Sending Domains

If you send from multiple domains or subdomains, authenticate each one. Never send from:

Unverified domains
Free email addresses (gmail.com, yahoo.com)
One-time inboxes

4. Use Google Postmaster Tools

This is essential for monitoring:

IP reputation
Domain reputation
Spam rates
Delivery errors
Inboxing improvements

Practical Reputation Protection (Simple, Everyday Tasks)

1. Remove Cold Subscribers Every 30 Days

Cold contacts (no opens for 60–90 days) destroy trust.

2. Send Only to Engaged Segments

Active 7 days
Active 30 days
Active 60 days

3. Limit Sending Frequency

Sending too often causes:

Fatigue
Spam reports
Lower engagement

4. Use Smart Send Time

This ensures each user receives emails when they’re most likely to open.

5. Clean Subject Lines

Avoid shouting, ALL CAPS, and clickbait. Clean subject lines look trustworthy.

6. Avoid Sudden Volume Spikes

Jumping from 10k/day to 50k/day overnight triggers filters.

How to Fix a Damaged Reputation

Step 1: Pause All Sending for 48–72 Hours

Step 2: Identify the Problem

Common causes:

High bounce rate
Spam complaints
Over-sending
Weak segmentation
Authentication issues

Step 3: Delete Cold Contacts

Remove anyone inactive for 90 days.

Step 4: Send Only to “Active 30 Days” Segment

This rebuilds trust quickly.

Step 5: Restart Warm-Up Schedule

Your reputation will rebuild within days or weeks depending on severity.

Companies Using Brevo to Improve Reputation

EcoLine Apparel — improved domain reputation after adopting warm-up schedules.
ModernPeak Digital — reduced spam complaints by 41% using smart segmentation.
BrightLeaf Wellness — boosted inbox placement through consistent engagement filtering.

Key Tip: Your first 1,000 emails determine your long-term reputation. Warm-up slowly, send to engaged segments, and avoid any risky behavior early.

Brevo Pricing & Included Features (2025)

Plan	Price	Reputation Management Features
Free	300 emails/day	Basic analytics, shared IP, simple bounce suppression, 1 sender identity.
Starter	$9/month	Enhanced deliverability, Smart Send Time, engagement analytics, 5,000 emails/month.
Standard	$18/month	A/B testing, advanced segmentation, send-time optimization, workflow-based list hygiene.
Professional	$499/month	Dedicated IP support, advanced deliverability suite, predictive scoring, reputation dashboard, blocklist monitoring.

Final Verdict

Sender reputation decides whether your marketing succeeds or collapses. With the right balance of authentication, engagement, smart sending, and consistent hygiene habits, Brevo becomes one of the safest and most reliable platforms for long-term inbox placement. Your reputation can improve quickly — but only if your behavior stays consistent. Clean sending = strong inboxing.

EmailSchool Recommendation

Protect your domain from day one. Avoid sudden spikes, send only to engaged users, and warm-up slowly. For deeper guidance and official resources, visit Brevo Official.

1. Warm up correctly
2. Maintain engagement-based segments
3. Automate your hygiene workflows

Continue Learning at EmailSchool